Medical writing workflow
Medical Writing QC Checklist: Claims, Data and Format Checks
A medical writing QC checklist is a list of checks run on a document before it is finalized or submitted. It should confirm that the document meets the brief and template, that every claim traces to a specific source passage, that numbers match, that terminology is consistent, and that formatting and sign-off are complete. Below is a practical version you can adapt.
What should a medical writing QC checklist cover?
Most published checklists, including those from medical communications agencies and professional bodies such as AMWA, group checks into the same few areas: scope, template, claims and evidence, data accuracy, consistency, tone and formatting. The checklist below follows that pattern and adds a documentation step so the review can be audited later.
Treat it as a starting template. Your sponsor's SOPs, the journal's instructions for authors, or your client's review process take priority wherever they differ.
1. Brief and deliverable scope
1. Brief and deliverable scope
- Does the document cover every topic, audience and deliverable named in the project brief?
- Is anything included that the brief excludes (for example, an out-of-scope indication or comparison)?
- Is the version of the brief you checked against the latest approved one?
2. Template and style compliance
2. Template and style compliance
- Is the correct sponsor, regulatory or journal template in use?
- Do headings, section order, numbering, table and figure styles match that template?
- Are house style rules applied (units, abbreviations, capitalisation of product names, spelling variant)?
3. Claims and evidence
This is the section where most rework originates, because every statement needs a traceable basis.
- Is every factual statement and conclusion linked to an approved source document or cited literature?
- Can you point to the specific passage (page, table or figure) in the specific reference, not just the reference as a whole?
- Does the wording match the strength of the evidence? Look for claims that overstate a finding, drop a qualifier, or generalise beyond the studied population.
- Does any source contradict or qualify the claim?
- Is each claim in a slide, abstract or summary also supported where it appears in the body?
4. Numerical accuracy
4. Numerical accuracy
- Do numbers in the text match the tables, figures and the original source?
- Are percentages, confidence intervals, p-values, sample sizes and units transcribed exactly?
- Are totals, denominators and rounding consistent across sections?
- Are numbers cited from a secondary source flagged so they can be checked against the primary one?
5. Internal consistency
5. Internal consistency
- Are terms, drug and product names, and abbreviations used the same way throughout, and defined at first use?
- Do cross-references (table, figure, section and appendix numbers) point to the right place?
- Do the abstract, summary, conclusions and body agree?
6. Tone and objectivity
6. Tone and objectivity
- Is the language neutral and appropriate to the audience?
- Are promotional or absolute words ("proven", "best", "always") either supported by evidence or removed?
- Are limitations and uncertainty represented rather than omitted?
7. References and citations
7. References and citations
- Does every in-text citation have an entry in the reference list, and vice versa?
- Do reference details (authors, year, journal, volume, pages, DOI) match the source document?
- Is the citation format the one the template requires?
8. Formatting and language
8. Formatting and language
- Final proofread for spelling, grammar and punctuation.
- Check headers, footers, page numbers, tracked changes, comments and hidden text.
- Check table and figure legibility, captions and footnotes.
9. Sign-off and documentation
9. Sign-off and documentation
- Was the QC done by someone other than the author, where your process requires it?
- Are findings logged with their resolution, the reviewer's initials and the date?
- Are the document version and the reference set that were checked recorded?
How do the main ways of running QC compare?
None of these removes the need for a reviewer's judgment. They differ in how much of the evidence trail you assemble yourself.
- Approach: Paper or Word checklist — Good for: Simple documents, quick adoption, any template — Weak spot: Claim-to-source mapping is manual and lives outside the document
- Approach: Spreadsheet claim log — Good for: Shared record of claims, sources and status — Weak spot: Easy to drift from the current draft; passages must be located by hand
- Approach: General PDF annotator — Good for: Highlights and comments on references and drafts — Weak spot: No claim mapping or cited copies; the reviewer builds the audit trail
- Approach: Claim-substantiation workspace such as Easy Annotation — Good for: Keeping the deliverable, its context and references together, and tracing claims to uploaded sources — Weak spot: PDF- and project-centric; does not decide whether a source supports a claim
Where does Easy Annotation fit in a QC checklist?
Easy Annotation is a claim-substantiation workspace for medical writers. It keeps a deliverable, its exact document context and the supporting references in one project. It identifies source-linked claims without altering the originals and searches only the references you upload to that project. It then produces cited copies with a reference list.
In terms of the checklist above, it supports section 3 (claims and evidence), section 4 (numerical accuracy) and section 7 (references). Its review labels are support, contradiction, qualification and exact numerical checks. These labels give you a prompt about what to look at. They do not replace your decision about whether a source supports a claim, because a relevant source does not necessarily support a claim. The tool also does not make regulatory or substantiation decisions.
This is most useful in a few situations:
- A freelance writer preparing manuscripts, slide decks or promotional content that has to survive MLR review.
- An agency team that wants a repeatable claim-review path across clients and projects.
- A reviewer who needs to confirm that each claim maps to a specific passage in a specific reference.
- A writer auditing an inherited deck, where the original support for each claim has to be reconstructed.
What does it cost, and how does the trial work?
Pricing is per writer. Published pricing has no team or seat-based tier.
Uploading, organising and annotating PDFs in Quick Annotation never uses credits. Claim review and cited copies do consume AI Processing Credits. Unused monthly credits carry into the next billing period, up to one month's worth. Subscribers can also buy one-time credit packs, which are used only after monthly credits and expire after 12 months. Payments are non-refundable, so use the trial to check the workflow fits before subscribing.
- Writer: USD $149.00 per month, or $1,490.00 per year billed annually, with 5,000 AI Processing Credits per month.
- Writer Plus: USD $299.00 per month, or $2,990.00 per year billed annually, with 12,000 AI Processing Credits per month.
- Launch offer: the first month of Writer monthly is USD $111.75 (25% off), then USD $149.00, for new subscribers until 31 December 2026.
- Free trial: 14 days including 1,000 AI Processing Credits. No payment details are needed, and the trial never converts automatically into a paid subscription.
How do you make the checklist your own?
How do you make the checklist your own?
- Start from the brief and template. Pull required sections, audiences and style rules into the first two categories.
- Write every item as a question with a clear pass or fail. "Is the sample size in the abstract identical to the results table?" is easier to verify than "Are numbers correct?"
- Add an evidence column. Record the page or table that supports each check so a second reviewer can follow it.
- Separate author checks from independent checks. The person who wrote a sentence is the worst-placed person to see its gaps.
- Version the checklist. When a review round finds a new type of error, add a line for it.
- Keep a short log. Note what was found, what changed and who signed off.
When to use something else
When to use something else
- You need real-time co-authoring in Word. Easy Annotation is PDF- and project-centric. A document collaboration suite is a better fit for simultaneous editing.
- You only need annotations and comments. If you do not need claim mapping or cited copies, a general PDF annotator such as Adobe Acrobat, LiquidText or Hypothesis may cost less and be enough. Check each tool's current features yourself.
- You need a team or seat-based plan. Easy Annotation's published plans are per writer.
- Your document is short and low-risk. A plain checklist in Word or a spreadsheet may be all you need.
- You want a tool to decide substantiation. Easy Annotation does not do this. The reviewer assesses support and uncertainty.
What is a medical writing QC checklist?
It is a structured list of checks a reviewer runs before a document is finalized or submitted. It typically covers the brief, template, claims and sources, numerical accuracy, consistency, formatting and sign-off. The reviewer decides whether each item passes.
How do you make a QC checklist for medical writing?
Start from the project brief and the sponsor, journal or regulatory template. Group checks by category, write each as a question a second person can answer, add a column for evidence and initials, and revise the list after each review round.
Does a QC checklist replace MLR or peer review?
No. A checklist makes your own review repeatable and documented before the document goes to others. Medical, legal and regulatory reviewers still make their own judgments.
Does Easy Annotation decide whether a source supports a claim?
No. It identifies source-linked claims, searches only the references uploaded to the project and produces cited copies with a reference list. The human reviewer assesses support and uncertainty.
Is there a free trial of Easy Annotation?
Yes. The trial lasts 14 days, includes 1,000 AI Processing Credits, requires no payment details and never converts automatically into a paid subscription. Uploading, organising and annotating PDFs in Quick Annotation never uses credits.
The takeaway
Yes. The trial lasts 14 days, includes 1,000 AI Processing Credits, requires no payment details and never converts automatically into a paid subscription. Uploading, organising and annotating PDFs in Quick Annotation never uses credits.